Ratings: Villa beat United after 18-match winless run against Red Devils; Dalot shone, Greenwood tried, Ronaldo had an off game


Manchester United fell to a 1-0 defeat to Aston Villa in the Premier League. It was the first league defeat of the season; the third in all competitions with two of those coming at Old Trafford. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s side lost both Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire to injury before seeing Kortney Hause head home in the 88th minute to put Villa ahead in the match. Edinson Cavani called for a penalty as Hause handled the ball in the box in added time and the penalty was given both by the referee and VAR. Bruno Fernandes took the penalty, sending it over the crossbar. United 18-match undefeated run against Villa is over.

United started well against Villa but the away side soon started to get into the game. United almost got in early with Mason Greenwood looking to break through the defence and find an early goal, but defensively, Villa were able to nip the attack in the bud. Greenwood is a live wire of a player and will push defences. Villa then had a chance, which at the time was the best chance of the game with Matt Targett off target, which should have not been the case because of how close he was to the goal. Villa then started to get their foot in and pressured United, who seemed defensively poor at the time with Harry Maguire making a mistake.

In the 29th minute of the match, Luke Shaw was booked for a challenge a few minutes later, after suffering a knock, could not continue so Solskjaer had to make his first substitution of the match with Diogo Dalot replacing him in the 34th minute of the match. At the end of the half, it was 0-0 despite both side trying to cause a dent in each others armour. United had 60.2% possession, having 15 shots on goal, with just two of those on target – which was not that great. United will need to be more clinical in the second half if they want to keep the pressure on Chelsea, Liverpool and Manchester City this season.

There were no changes by either team at the start of the second half of the match. There seemed to be a fiery atmosphere to the second half of the match with Villa seeking to press United and demanding to be noticed. Ollie Watkins seemed to break through, although he seemed to be offside, and he was. Maguire seemed to be carrying a knock in the 53rd minute of the match and needed treatment on the pitch. Maguire continued by Victor Lindelof got himself warmed up and ready to come on but Maguire was happy to continue, for now. Cristiano Ronaldo started an attack with Paul Pogba shooting on goal, but was just off target.

There was some frustration with John McGinn, who seemed to be fouled by Maguire, who with his calf injury, would not have caught him on a run. McGinn was annoyed that nothing was given and minutes later took out his frustration on Bruno Fernandes, swiping at his ankle. He was booked for that foul but still seemed to moan at the referee. Solskjaer brought Lindelof on for Maguire in the 67th minute of the match. Seconds later, Villa were on the attack with David De Gea making a good save, sending the ball into the midfield. United were on the attack through Greenwood with Ronaldo getting forward, but offside and Greenwood shot and missed.

United seemed to be more adventurous at this late stage of the match with Villa seeking to do all they could to get a goal or stop United from scoring one. In the 82nd minute of the match, Solskjaer made his third substitution, this time not because of an injury, bringing Edinson Cavani back from injury and replacing Scott McTominay, who returned from groin surgery last weekend. United will continue to attack the Villa and seek to win this match but Villa will give them as much, seeking to get a win over United. In the 88th minute of the match, Kortney Hause headed a goal for the away side with the Villa fans erupting in celebration.

United won a penalty in added time after Hause seemed to handle the ball in the box. The referee gave the penalty, as did VAR. Bruno Fernandes took the penalty and missed it with United set to suffer back to back defeats for the first time this season, their third defeat of the season including the Champions League opener to Young Boys almost a fortnight ago. It is not the best result for United, who seemed to be especially poor in the second half. Villa took all three points from this match, which they enjoyed as it is the first time in 18 matches that they won – their last victory over United came in December 2009.

United will be back in Champions League action on Wednesday evening as they welcome Villarreal, the team who beat them on penalties in the Europa League final last season, to Old Trafford. United will need to end their run of defeats, winning once in their last four matches in all competitions. The defeats to Young Boys, West Ham United and now Aston Villa could be costly for them this season. Old Trafford was the place that defeats cost them last season and despite the good start at home, last season seems to have come calling. United can only hope that Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire are not out of action for a long time.

Manchester United

1 David De Gea

Seemed calm despite the defensive chaos around him. Made a great second half save to deny Villa. Beaten two minutes from time though.


29 Aaron Wan-Bissaka

Had a quiet match against Villa. Solid defensively, as is almost always the case. Seemed to make decisions late at times, which is not good., especially when seeking to attack - which we need to see more of.


19 Raphael Varane

Had to put a lot of work in at the back and seemed solid when doing that. Kept his position and was definitely the strong link in the defence.


5 Harry Maguire

Seemed a bit off his game at the start of the match and prone to errors. Soon settled into the game but got a knock to the calf, which he seemed to recover from but had to come off for Lindelof in the 67th minute of the match.


23 Luke Shaw

The left-back played well against Villa and looked to be in form again. He was booked for a challenge in the 29th minute of the match, receiving a knock soo after. In the 34th minute of the match he could not continue and was replaced by Dalot.


17 Fred

Struggled to control the game. Will no doubt be the scape goat again as many do not like him. Passing was not good and could not control the pressure.


39 Scott McTominay

Seemed a bit more confident in himself after his injury setback and his early return last week. Settled in and did what was needed partnering Fred in the midfield. He was replaced by Cavani in the 82nd minute of the match with United needing a goal to win the game.


11 Mason Greenwood

Lively throughout the match. Consistent when seeking to score. Seemed to do more than others, as he did against the Hammers in midweek. His finishing was not as good as it has been.


18 Bruno Fernandes

He was involved from start to finish. Stood up to the challenge and did what he needed to do. Took the penalty, which could have levelled the match - and missed him. 15 taken, 13 scored.


6 Paul Pogba

Had a bright start to the game and had a chance to score from an attack, but was off target. Perhaps it was not a match for him to shine in. Time for a change to this formation perhaps?


7 Cristiano Ronaldo

Did not seem to be able to get into this match. Marking Ronaldo did not really create space for others. Perhaps two strikers are needed? Had some threat from the wide areas when he was on the ball, which is where Pogba's chance came from.



20 Diogo Dalot

Replaced Shaw 34'. Did well to contain Cash, which was where Shaw was struggling. Made some good runs on the attack, which was good to see. He will probably be the right-back on Wednesday with Wan-Bissaka suspended.


2 Victor Lindelof

Replaced Maguire 67'. Looked pretty comfortable when he came on, despite the chaos United were in at the time. Settled into the game and did all he could do.


21 Edinson Cavani

Replaced McTominay 82'. Hause got away from him which resulted in Villa's goal. Came on too late


Goals: Kortney Hause 88′

Assists: Douglas Luiz 88′

Manchester United: De Gea; Wan-Bissaka, Varane, Maguire (Lindelof 67′), Shaw (Dalot 34′); Fred, McTominay (Cavani 82′); Greenwood, Fernandes, Pogba; Ronaldo

Substitutes Not Used: Heaton; Lingard, Matic, Van de Beek; Martial, Sancho

Bookings: Luke Shaw 29′, Fred 77′; John McGinn 66′, Matty Cash 90′

Written by John Walker

Other news you may also like

2 January 2020

Wolverhampton Wanderers -v- Manchester United Emirates FA Cup Molineux Stadium, Wolverhampton Saturday 4 January 2020, KO 17:30 GMT Referee: Paul Tierney … Read more

9 January 2021

At the start of August last year, it was widely reported that Jadon Sancho was, depending where you read, either close to agreeing personal terms, according to Sky S… Read more

14 May 2020

Manchester United are reportedly monitoring Schalke 04 winger Rabbi Matondo as a possible back-up option should the club not manage to sign Borussia Dortmund winger Ja… Read more

3 September 2020

Manchester United are preparing to finalise agent salary and fees before submitting an official offer to Borussia Dortmund for Jadon Sancho, according to the Daily Mai… Read more

copyright: JW